Pioneer
| Image | Name | Flair Text | Abbreviated | Total Users |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Butler Bulldogs | Butler Bulldogs | Butler | 75 |
| Davidson Wildcats | Davidson Wildcats | Davidson | 77 |
| Dayton Flyers | Dayton Flyers | Dayton | 238 |
| Drake Bulldogs | Drake Bulldogs | Drake | 99 |
| Marist Red Foxes | Marist Red Foxes | Marist | 61 |
| Morehead State Eagles | Morehead State Eagles | Morehead State | 51 |
| Presbyterian Blue Hose | Presbyterian Blue Hose | Presbyterian | 66 |
| San Diego Toreros | San Diego Toreros | San Diego | 89 |
| St. Thomas Tommies | St. Thomas Tommies | St. Thomas | 141 |
| Stetson Hatters | Stetson Hatters | Stetson | 74 |
| Valparaiso Beacons | Valparaiso Beacons | Valparaiso | 47 |