Midwest
| Image | Name | Flair Text | Abbreviated | Total Users |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Beloit Buccaneers | Beloit Buccaneers | Beloit | 9 |
| Chicago Maroons | Chicago Maroons | Chicago | 335 |
| Cornell (IA) Rams | Cornell (IA) Rams | Cornell (IA) | 22 |
| Grinnell Pioneers | Grinnell Pioneers | Grinnell | 30 |
| Illinois College Blueboys | Illinois College Blueboys | Illinois College | 9 |
| Knox Prairie Fire | Knox Prairie Fire | Knox | 20 |
| Lake Forest Foresters | Lake Forest Foresters | Lake Forest | 10 |
| Lawrence Vikings | Lawrence Vikings | Lawrence | 15 |
| Monmouth (IL) Fighting Scots | Monmouth (IL) Fighting Scots | Monmouth (IL) | 14 |
| Ripon Red Hawks | Ripon Red Hawks | Ripon | 5 |