Mid-States
| Image | Name | Flair Text | Abbreviated | Total Users |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Defiance Yellow Jackets | Defiance Yellow Jackets | Defiance | 13 |
| Indiana Wesleyan Wildcats | Indiana Wesleyan Wildcats | Indiana Wesleyan | 13 |
| Judson Eagles | Judson Eagles | Judson | |
| Lawrence Tech Blue Devils | Lawrence Tech Blue Devils | Lawrence Tech | 15 |
| Madonna Crusaders | Madonna Crusaders | Madonna | 8 |
| Marian (IN) Knights | Marian (IN) Knights | Marian (IN) | 16 |
| Olivet Nazarene Tigers | Olivet Nazarene Tigers | Olivet Nazarene | 13 |
| Siena Heights Saints | Siena Heights Saints | Siena Heights | 11 |
| St. Francis (IL) Fighting Saints | St. Francis (IL) Fighting Saints | St. Francis (IL) | 3 |
| St. Francis (IN) Cougars | St. Francis (IN) Cougars | St. Francis (IN) | 32 |
| St. Xavier Cougars | St. Xavier Cougars | St. Xavier | 6 |
| Taylor Trojans | Taylor Trojans | Taylor | 10 |