Heartland
| Image | Name | Flair Text | Abbreviated | Total Users |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anderson (IN) Ravens | Anderson (IN) Ravens | Anderson (IN) | 9 |
| Bluffton Beavers | Bluffton Beavers | Bluffton | 18 |
| Franklin Grizzlies | Franklin Grizzlies | Franklin | 17 |
| Hanover Panthers | Hanover Panthers | Hanover | 11 |
| Manchester Spartans | Manchester Spartans | Manchester | 7 |
| Mount St. Joseph Lions | Mount St. Joseph Lions | Mount St. Joseph | 9 |
| Rose-Hulman Engineers | Rose-Hulman Engineers | Rose-Hulman | 52 |