Great Midwest
| Image | Name | Flair Text | Abbreviated | Total Users |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ashland Eagles | Ashland Eagles | Ashland | 32 |
| Findlay Oilers | Findlay Oilers | Findlay | 38 |
| Hillsdale Chargers | Hillsdale Chargers | Hillsdale | 33 |
| Kentucky Wesleyan Panthers | Kentucky Wesleyan Panthers | Kentucky Wesleyan | 5 |
| Lake Erie Storm | Lake Erie Storm | Lake Erie | 4 |
| Northwood Timberwolves | Northwood Timberwolves | Northwood | 37 |
| Ohio Dominican Panthers | Ohio Dominican Panthers | Ohio Dominican | 24 |
| Thomas More Saints | Thomas More Saints | Thomas More | 20 |
| Tiffin Dragons | Tiffin Dragons | Tiffin | 20 |
| Walsh Cavaliers | Walsh Cavaliers | Walsh | 8 |